rjkyln This combo is really interesting, I totally get why you’d pause — especially if it’s someone new but the cards keep leaning toward past-heavy or karmic stuff.
6 of Cups can absolutely mean nostalgia or a past connection, but it doesn’t always mean an ex or childhood friend. Sometimes it pops up when a bond feels emotionally familiar or comforting, that “I’ve known you forever” vibe even if the person is brand new.
With Judgement and Justice clarifying, I’m leaning toward karmic or balancing energy. Maybe this person is helping you rewrite an old story, heal something that’s lingered, or finally give or receive the emotional openness that was missing.
5 of Pentacles reversed and 5 of Swords reversed read like someone coming out of a rough patch — learning to connect again after feeling excluded, guarded, or hurt. Add King of Cups and the Page/Knight of Cups and it paints emotional growth and readiness, not just for romance but for deeper emotional maturity.
So even if there’s no literal shared past, 6 of Cups might be pointing to emotional familiarity or a soul-level recognition. This could be someone helping you reconnect to a kind of love you’ve been craving. My two cents: don’t dismiss the new person just because the cards look past-focused, sometimes the past shows up to be healed through the present.